Chandlery September 2019 Issue

New Goyer Guard vs. Firehose

Strong, single-layer chafe gear holds up in bench testing and onboard.


 
It has been a while since we tested chafe gear (see PS October 2012), or since we described how to make your own chafe gear, so when Goyer Marine announced a new chafe gear product, we jumped on the chance to test it. 

However, shortly after the following report was published, some readers notified us that Goyer no longer carried the product we had tested. Here is the explanation we received from Goyer.

Unfortunately we had to suspend production for now, as our chafe guard business failed to take off and bills were piling up. I am hoping it is temporary, and encourage everyone interested to go on our website and sign up for our email list. That way I can guage interest and look and getting back up and running in the near future. 

Practical Sailor apologizes to readers for any inconvenience. If you don't want to wait and see if Goyer gets production back up and running, there are other options. 

Note that long-standing manufacturer of chafe gear, Fjord, does make a polyurethane-coated commercial version of a chafe protection product that we've tested rigorously. We have not yet tested the commercial version, but will be testing in the future. According to Fjord, this product offers a level of protection comparable to the Goyer products described below. 

We hope Goyer can sort out their production issues.

For what it's worth, here's the rest of the description of the apparently discontinued Goyer product:

The weave is very similar to tubular climbing webbing, although made of polyester instead of nylon and with a slightly looser weave. Rainwater can permeate the Bulk Jacket Guard, cooling the rope and providing lubrication.

The HT and HE versions are treated with a resin that makes them far more wear resistant but effectively waterproof. All three products are nominally two inches wide and will accommodate ropes up to 1-inch.

Drew Frye

The Goyer chafe guard comes in three different grades. Goyer’s thinner profile fits well in smaller chocks commonly found on small boats.

FireHose Bulk Jacket

Soft, flexible, and easy to fit. Though fluffier than Bluewater tubular nylon climbing webbing (see PS November 2015), it measures the same thickness (~ 2 mm ) under light pressure from a micrometer. Although abrasion resistance was generally good, the looser weave allowed the cinder block to snag a thread and pull. 6 feet for $19.

Bottom line: Climbing webbing is more durable and a better value.

FireHose XT Custom Guard.

This is the same webbing as bulk firehose, but saturated with a polyurethane resin. The webbing becomes slightly stiffer and more wear resistant, placing it on a par with Bluewater webbing after coating with Maxijacket, but with less stiffness. This is a potent combination, perhaps the best compromise for off the shelf dock line chafe protection that we’ve seen yet. It sold in pre-cut lengths of 14 inches for $15, and 6 feet for $28.

Bottom line: Good for dock lines and for mooring pendants.

FireHose HE Custom Guard

A heavier dose of resin results in an even tougher guard. We even extended the test interval by four times, and still the webbing was barely scuffed.

The down side is that it becomes quite stiff, perhaps a little annoying to work with on docklines. That said, we’d still choose it for tough applications because of the thin profile, and we like it a lot for mooring pendants.

If you wear through this, there is something very wrong with the lead. Eighteen inches for $25.

Bottom line: Good or mooring pendants and Recommended for heavy duty dockline situations.

Drew Frye

The firehose was chafed through, but the heavily scuffed Goyer was intact.

Conclusion

A weakness of multi-layer and plastic tubing chafe guards is they are often too fat to fit into the chock, or at least we’ve always struggled with that. By the time we get the line size we want, there is hardly room for a guard. Single layer guards, like climbing webbing (preferably coated with Maxijacket) and Chafepro, solve this problem, eliminating any reason not to use them. Ever since we’ve improved the chafe gear in our ground tackle equation, we sleep better, knowing there is an extra layer protecting our snubbers or rodes. 

[Note that this article is an update to the print version that appeared in the Sept. 2019 issue].



Comments (5)

I like plastic tubing because it is dependable. A chock won't abrade it and it won't abrade a toerail. It lasts for almost ever. In a hurricane it might heat up and melt the line or is that true? Practical Sailor might want to test that theory.

Posted by: Sue | August 27, 2019 1:26 PM    Report this comment

I have been using fire hose sprayed with SailKote which get wonderfully slippery after two applications of the spray and shows no serious wear after a season of use on my dock lines.

Posted by: Chriscod | August 27, 2019 12:07 PM    Report this comment

Hi guys- nice article on Goyer Guard except that the company has ceased operations as of this writing!

Posted by: sailalibi | August 27, 2019 10:17 AM    Report this comment

I'm a little confused by the title. "Goyer Guard" refers to Goyer's Firehose XT custom guard chafe guard or Firehose HE custom guard chafe guard and "Firehose" refers to Goyer's Firehose bulk jacket chafe guard? All three products are Goyer, Firehose, and guards.

BTW, all guard products on Goyer's website are sold out, they are not producing any more product at this time, and Firehose HE is not listed as a product.

Posted by: ewdysar | August 27, 2019 10:01 AM    Report this comment

I'm a little confused by the title. "Goyer Guard" refers to Goyer's Firehose XT custom guard chafe guard or Firehose HE custom guard chafe guard and "Firehose" refers to Goyer's Firehose bulk jacket chafe guard? All three products are Goyer, Firehose, and guards.

BTW, all guard products on Goyer's website are sold out, they are not producing any more product at this time, and Firehose HE is not listed as a product.

Posted by: ewdysar | August 27, 2019 10:01 AM    Report this comment

New to Practical Sailor?
Register for Free!

Already Registered?
Log In